The Butcher and The Blade and Every Time I Die’s Radical

Every Time I Die didn’t really do much for me the first time I heard them. My introduction to the band was 2003’s Hot Damn, and while I appreciated what they were attempting to do, it just didn’t click with me for whatever reason. That all changed when the Buffalo, NY quintet came roaring back with Gutter Phenomenon in 2005; that album’s combination of caustic metallic hardcore and greasy southern rock riffage totally hit the spot on songs such as “Easy Tiger” “The New Black” and “Guitared and Feathered.” There wasn’t another band that sounded quite like ETID and Gutter Phenomenon stayed in heavy rotation for quite some time.

But for reasons I can’t really explain, Every Time I Die fell off my musical radar after about a year. It could be because I was losing interest in the metalcore scene as a whole by then, or because my listening was being dominated by obscure (at the time) black metal bands such as Xasthur, Urfaust, Circle of Ouroborus and Nuit Noire, or it could’ve simply been because there was so much amazing music being released at the time that some bands, including ETID, were unfairly pushed aside.

Now fast forward to November 27, 2019. I’m watching All Elite Wrestling and a new tag team debuts by coming up through the ring canvass and beating the crap out of Cody Rhodes. The commentators explained that the team was known as The Butcher and The Blade and I immediately found myself intrigued by their unique appearance. They went on to become quite prominent on AEW television, challenging for the tag team titles and feuding with the likes of the Young Bucks and FTR. They came off like an eccentric, twisted pair of mercenaries or hitmen, sort of like Diamond Dallas Page and Danny Trejo’s characters in The Devil’s Rejects or The Plague in Hobo with a Shotgun.

Over the course of watching The Butcher and The Blade’s ascent in AEW, it was revealed that The Butcher was none other than Every Time I Die guitarist Andy Williams; it had been nearly fifteen years since Gutter Phenomenon, so there was no way I would have recognized him on my own, but just like that, ETID reentered my consciousness. At the time the band didn’t have anything new going on (they hadn’t released an album since 2016) but I filed the information away to see if this unlikely intersection of my two loves (heavy music and pro wrestling) would lead anywhere interesting.

Fast forward yet again to the end of 2021 and Every Time I Die released Radical, their ninth album overall and first in five years. I recently picked up a copy of Radical at my local shop, and after numerous listens I couldn’t be happier to have ETID back on my playlist. The band are still dishing out their unique brand of hard rockin’ metalcore on Radical, but it’s evident that they’ve also continued to evolve in surprising ways since my last encounter with them all those years ago.

Make no mistake, ETID are still plenty corrosive; songs like “Dark Distance” “All This and War” and “The Whip” are as nasty as it gets, but they’ve also learned to temper their crushing metallic hardcore salvos with an even greater emphasis on catchy songwriting, as evidenced by tracks such as “Planet Shit” “Post-Boredom” and “White Void.” The band even displays it’s tender side on the delicate, ballad-esque “The Thing with Feathers,” a song dedicated to vocalist Keith Buckley’s sister who passed away in 2017.

Speaking of Buckley, his vocal performance and lyrics on Radical are nothing short of outstanding. He switches from acidic screams and barks to heartfelt cleans with ease, matching the music blow for blow as it morphs from hard rocking grooves to all-out brutality and all points in-between. Buckley is also in absolute top form lyrically; the aforementioned “Planet Shit” in particular is a scathing criticism of post-Trump America, with lines like “Coming live from planet shit / our only hope was in a murdered kid / the one god we had went off the grid / no future with a racist past / oh but we can’t acknowledge that / so we burn a cross and pray to a flag” and “The karma wheel is flat / even the ten commandments cracked / there’s no law when the outlaw wears a badge.”

The rest of the band are no slouches either; guitarists Jordan Buckley and Andy Williams peel off riff after killer riff like it’s no big deal while bassist Stephen Miccichie and new(ish) drummer Clayton Holyoak bring the rhythmic thunder. The band as a whole sounds tight, focused and utterly ferocious, tearing through each track as if they still have something to prove after over two decades in the game. It’s evident that Every Time I Die had saved up near-superhuman levels of energy, aggression and intensity during the five years between albums and then poured all of that molten fury into these sixteen songs.

Of course, it doesn’t hurt that Radical sounds like a million bucks thanks to producer Will Putney (Body Count, Pig Destroyer, Psycroptic, etc.); the Fit For An Autopsy guitarist clearly knows his way around a recording studio and brings out the best in ETID here. The album is loud and heavy all hell, yet it possesses a level of clarity that’s refreshing in this era of metal and hardcore albums that are brick-walled to shit. Each instrument can be heard perfectly and Buckley’s vocals sit perfectly in the mix without overpowering the music.

All in all, Radical is a fantastic album that very likely would’ve made my year end list if I’d heard it just a little sooner. The band’s fusion of metal and hardcore’s explosive aggression with hard rock’s catchiness and groove, plus a penchant for varied songwriting is right up my alley and the more I listen to it, the more I’m kicking myself for losing track of the band in the first place. This is easily some of the best metalcore I’ve heard in the last ten years and anyone like me who has been foolishly sleeping on ETID for all of these years does so at their own peril.

I love it when my obsessions intersect, and thanks to AEW reintroducing Every Time I Die to my musical universe, not only do I get to enjoy Radical, I get to go back and discover the band’s substantial back catalog. Although The Butcher and The Blade seem to have gotten a bit lost in the shuffle as AEW’s roster continues to grow, I’m hopeful they’ll eventually get another chance to shine as one of the promotion’s top tag teams. Their gimmick would work perfectly for Malakai Black’s upcoming House of Black faction, but that my friends is another article all together.

https://everytimeidie.bandcamp.com/album/radical

https://everytimeidie.net/

Unru – Demo MMXIII (Caligari Records, 2013)

ta1

Fledgling cassette label Caligari Records has already impressed  me once this year with their maiden release, the nasty-ass blackened thrash assault of DeathCult’s The Test of Time, and just a few short months later they’re back to deliver the black metal tape TKO to the skull of 2013 with the debut demo from Germany’s Unru.
Continue reading “Unru – Demo MMXIII (Caligari Records, 2013)”

Shai Hulud – Reach Beyond the Sun (Metal Blade, 2013)

11183_JKTSince 1995, Shai Hulud has been one of the leading lights of metalcore. I’m not talking about metalcore as in: “Hey! Let’s rip off Slaughter of the Soul and throw in some breakdowns!” I’m talking metalcore as in the metallic hardcore that evolved out of crossover; a true fusion of the heartfelt aggression of hardcore and the compositional complexity of heavy metal (ok, I know that description sounds like it came straight from a PR e-mail blast, but it’s the fucking truth).

Continue reading “Shai Hulud – Reach Beyond the Sun (Metal Blade, 2013)”

Early Graves – Red Horse (No Sleep Records, 2012)

If you were to listen to Early Graves’ Red Horse without knowing anything about the band’s history, you’d probably never guess that this is a band that has risen from the ashes of tragedy.  This is not a band that sounds broken down or beaten; this is a band that sounds lean, mean and hungry, ready to raise Hell and rip some fucking heads off.  It is a testament to Early Graves’ intestinal fortitude that they were not only able to recover from losing their original vocalist in a horrible accident, but to write, record and release their definitive album (so far) in the process.
Continue reading “Early Graves – Red Horse (No Sleep Records, 2012)”